"1. Given that the U.S. economy is based on consumer spending, is it patriotic to shop? "
Some may argue, or re-butte that to survive in America, especially in our current state of recession, that it would be wise to not shop. But rather to save, pay off bills, and to spend wisely to ensure a comfortable living state. But, of those of us who are aware of the trickle down theory, in the long run, spending money in the shopping market, is better for the economy, maybe not with immediate gratification, but is it not a common goal to want what is best for the future generations, to make the world, (especially America) a better place!?
It is no secret that a lot of American products are not made in America, nor by American workers. So the argument there would be that the money from the sale of that product is not being returned to the American system. This, while it reveals some reality, is not entirely true. For one, the taxes added on to the item stay in America, so even if the money made from the actual item itself leaves America, the taxes will stay. Second, the seller (store) gets a cut of the profit, so that will stay. And thirdly, and the most important point of this list, is that if people shopped more, America, and product making corporations would have more money to make, and pay American workers. The big reason that America has things like sweatshops, is because people in other places will take lower wages to do the same work. But if more people shopped, America would be able to pay reasonable wages for the amount of inflation in America. So we could have American workers in American factories making such things as clothes, shoes, bags, etc. And being paid a good wage for it.
The conclusion I got was that it is not American to stop shopping. The number of Premises were two. Economy and Goods are not made in America. The Economy is one reason that People are not shopping. Goods are not made in America. So the jobs that need to make the goods is cheaper in other part of the world.
ReplyDeleteYes i do find the argument valid. She gives details about what is or is not being American. She also gives clear reason about what is happening in America. The argument was telling us what happens. when we do not shop. People are not having jobs due to jobs over seas.
I do find the structure of the argument was clear. That there was a very good intro . The intro got my attention about the subject. It was very free flowing no extra adding and stayed on topic. Spelling was good and how it made you think if you were supporting America.
No it did not . It was free flowing and did not give me strange sentences. It was clear and very easy to read. Everything made it easy to read and not asking what is that word. Overall the argument gave a very good storyline how America is struggling